Print
Boston Globe

Luxor Café offers a taste of Egypt in Harvard Square

By Valerie Wencis Globe correspondent,Updated March 25, 2025, 10:00 a.m.

The Dubai Chocolate French Toast at Luxor Café.
The Dubai Chocolate French Toast at Luxor Café.Jonathan Wiggs/Globe Staff

Aficionados of Darwin’s — the beloved coffee shop with multiple Cambridge outposts that closed its doors at the end of 2022 after 30 years during the pandemic — cautiously eyed its flagship location on Mt. Auburn Street as it changed hands multiple times since. But the current iteration, Luxor Café, seems to have staying power.

Walking through its doors, one feels transported to Egypt, from the expansive stone wall of hieroglyphics to the evocative vocals of Umm Kulthum playing overhead. Wander downstairs, and you’ll find an intimate space reminiscent of an Egyptian tea salon, with poppy and pomegranate cushioned benches, dangling mosaic lamps, and iridescent sadaf tiled tables. It appears no detail was spared in the rebirth of this space, down to the stunning, sadaf-tiled double-sink-and-mirror bathroom.

But perhaps what most harkens back to the motherland is the name itself — the capital of ancient Egypt, Luxor is known for its abundance of monuments, temples, and tombs — as well as the scarab logo. Holding a to-go cup adorned with what he calls the “cartoon version” of the scarab with a coffee bean for a body, owner Abdelrahman (“Abdel”) Hassan explains that the oval beetle “symbolizes rebirth, health, rejuvenation — basically a lot of stuff that food and coffee does for you.”

Print
NBC Boston

Empty storefronts have doubled in Cambridge

There were 109 empty ground-floor storefronts across Cambridge as of last fall, 25% more than there were a year earlier and double the number there were in 2019, according to city data

By Greg Ryan  Published March 19, 2025  Updated on March 19, 2025 at 2:56 pm

Cambridge city councilors are upset their neighborhoods are seeing more vacant storefronts. They’re also upset they can’t seem to do much about it.

There were 109 empty ground-floor storefronts across Cambridge as of last fall, 25% more than there were a year earlier and double the number there were in 2019, according to city data. Nearly half of the storefronts have been empty for at least two years. A few, like the former AMC Loews theater in Harvard Square that closed in 2012, have been vacant for much longer.

Print
Boston Uncovered

This Hidden Pizza Spot Has Fed Bill Gates, Mark Zuckerberg, Matt Damon, and Ben Affleck

This hidden gem pizzeria tucked off Winthrop Street offers some of the best Sicilian slices in the Boston area!

 Ameera Hammouda – Senior Staff Writer • March 24, 2025

exterior of white brick building
Pinocchio’s Pizza & Subs

With a hidden side door on Winthrop Street in Harvard Square, it’s easy to miss Pinocchio’s Pizza & Subs—and it’d be a shame to do so. The pizza spot fed many high-profile figures from tech moguls to Hollywood A-listers before they were famous, such as Mark Zuckerberg, Ryan Fitzpatrick, Matt Damon, and Ben Affleck. Step inside and the walls are lined with all the icons who’ve enjoyed a slice, or a pie, from Pinocchio’s.

The Sicilian-style pizza spot’s been around since 1966, moving to Harvard Square in the 1980s! Their most beloved slice is the Sicilian tomato basil. Try any of their square Sicilian slices—you won’t be disappointed.

While it’s a hidden gem due to its sequestered entrance, the pizza spot is incredibly popular among Harvard Students, especially for late night grubs or after a Harvard-Yale game. Regulars simply call is “Noch’s.” As noted in the hit series, Suits, everyone at Harvard knows this is the place for the Square’s best square.

Print
WROR

PopUp Bagels to Open Second Boston-Area Location in Cambridge

Author Michael Vyskocil

March 24th 9:35 AM

Stock Image

A growing group of bagel shops that launched from a backyard pickup window in Connecticut is opening another Boston-area location.

NBC10 News Boston reported that PopUp Bagels is planning to open in Cambridge’s Harvard Square, 1430 Massachusetts Ave., later this year. The six-story, 50,000-square-foot College House building will be the base for its Cambridge business. According to a company news release, PopUp Bagels will serve hot, whole bagels meant to be “gripped, ripped, and dipped” into the brand’s specialty schmears, which include Calabrian Chili Butter and Sour Cream & Onion Cream Cheese.

An opening date for the Harvard Square location has not been announced.

PopUp Bagels has experienced rapid expansion since it debuted in Boston’s Seaport District. Another bagel shop is being planned for Somerville’s Assembly Row. Local franchisee Brian Harrington is directing all the Boston-area locations.

“After the success of our Seaport location and the great feedback from Assembly Row, it’s clear that Bostonians love what we’re doing,” said PopUp founder Adam Goldberg in an interview with What Now Boston. “We’re excited to bring hot bagels to Harvard Square and continue growing our presence in the city.”

Goldberg launched PopUp Bagels in 2020 from his home in Westport, Connecticut. The brand has since expanded to 10 locations across Connecticut, New York, and Massachusetts, and several Florida extensions are in the works.

Learn more about PopUp Bagels on the company’s website.

Print
Boston Globe

The Greater Boston Food Bank hosts a star-studded fund-raiser; PopUp Bagels to open in Harvard Square

By Kara Baskin Globe Correspondent,Updated March 20, 2025, 11:09 a.m.

Customers Maddy Estenson, Sam Burg, and Alex Wilk dip their hot bagels into various schmears at PopUp Bagels' new Seaport location in Boston.
Customers Maddy Estenson, Sam Burg, and Alex Wilk dip their hot bagels into various schmears at PopUp Bagels’ new Seaport location in Boston.Erin Clark/Globe Staff/Erin Clark

Fund-raisersThe Greater Boston Food Bank (GBFB) hosts a Taste of the Food Bank fund-raiser on Thursday, May 8, at their Yawkey Distribution Center (70 South Bay Ave.). They aim to raise $1 million to support hunger relief.

Jody Adams (La Padrona) and Steve DiFillippo (Davio’s) host the event, with lots of acclaimed chefs and mixologists on the roster. Taste food from Karen Akunowicz (Bar Volpe; Fox & the Knife); Joanne Chang (FlourMyers + Chang); Andy Husbands (The Smoke Shop); Erin Miller (Urban Hearth); Peter Nguyễn (Le Madeline); Cassie Piuma (Sarma); Douglass Williams (MIDA); and lots more. See the full lineup and get tickets at www.tasteofthefoodbank.com.

Chef Douglass Williams is on the GBFB lineup.
Chef Douglass Williams is on the GBFB lineup.Emily Kan Photography

In Boston, Stillwater and Sloane’s chef-owner Sarah Wade runs a Stillwater Strong fund-raiser to support residents in her native Oklahoma as they battle wildfires, particularly in the town of Stillwater.

Twenty percent of sales from pork mac and cheese at Stillwater (120 Kingston St.) and an Oklahoma onion burger at Sloane’s (197 N Harvard St.) will go to United Way Payne County; Wade will also donate $2 from each “Oklahoma Strong” Old Fashioned cocktail. The fund-raiser runs through Tuesday, April 1.

Save the dateTaste of Somerville happens at Boynton Yards (101 South St.) on Wednesday, June 14; the event traditionally benefits a local charity and features some of the city’s most-loved restaurants: CelesteJulietLa BrasaUnion Square Donuts, and more. Check out the details at www.tasteofsomerville.org.

Coming soon: New York-based PopUp Bagels expands to Harvard Square later this year (1430 Massachusetts Ave.), joining a busy Seaport location and an upcoming one at Assembly Row. They’re known for serving whole bagels with a side of schmears in flavors both classic and unusual, like spicy vodka sauce and pumpkin spice.

Print
Cambridge Day

More storefronts are going empty in Cambridge, but there are few tools available to reverse trend

More storefronts are going empty in Cambridge, but there are few tools available to reverse trend

By Madison Lucchesi

Tuesday, March 18, 2025

Marc LevyBy April 2017, the AMC Loews theater in Cambridge’s Harvard Square had been closed for five years and city councillors were threatening Gerald Chan with a land seizure. It has never been leased.

There’s really one tool Cambridge has to get deadbeat property owners to fill long-empty commercial spaces with tenants: Getting them to show up and explain themselves.

City councillors explained their shortage of options in fixing Cambridge’s worsening vacant storefront problem Monday after getting advice from the city solicitor at a March 11 committee meeting.

People want the city to “tax and fine the heck out of people who sit on their property,” councillor Paul Toner said. “We were advised that we actually cannot do that, and especially we cannot target just one property owner.”

“Our leverage in terms of forcing people to rent their space is nothing really, very little. But we do have the power of the pulpit,” vice mayor Marc McGovern said. “We do have the ability to call people in and hold them accountable for why properties are sitting, five, six, seven, 10 years vacant.”

A meeting with those property owners – none of whom were mentioned by name in either meeting – will be scheduled, Toner said.

Developer Gerald Chan’s AMC Loews theater on Church Street in Harvard Square has been empty for more than 12.5 years, and in year five city councillors threatened him with a land taking if he didn’t develop a plan for its use; the space has never been leased. Chan presented a plan for a 60,000-square-foot building with two lower-level movie screens; street retail; and five stories of office space. He wanted to cover the building’s facade with digital screens. There’s been no action on the plan since a June 2019 test of the cladding.

At the March 11 meeting, business experts urged officials to appreciate the many reasons for empty storefronts and to separate small property owners who are doing their best in hard times from the handful of big property owners seeming to make no effort to fill spaces.

As of November, there were 109 ground-level storefront vacancies in Cambridge, according to the city’s Economic Opportunity and Development department, which does six-month surveys. Forty-six percent of those are considered long-term vacancies because they’ve been vacant more than two years – though a few of these spaces have leases pending, department director Pardis Saffari told councillors at the meeting of their Economic Development & University Relations Committee.

City data goes back to the fall of 2019, when the figure was 54 storefront vacancies.

“It doubled in five years. And I think we have a softening retail market where it could double in the next five years,” said Michael Monestime, president of the Central Square Business Improvement District.

“What happened in that time was a pandemic where people started working from home, people are eating less at the restaurants. Everyone’s online shopping for the ease of it,” Monestime said. “Traditionally, what we use ground-floor retail for is just a dinosaur, almost. We need to be creative about how we activate our commercial districts and what ground floor means.”

Reasons for empty spaces

Considering the changes in the nature of retail, it may be time to look again at zoning law that demands ground-floor retail space be included when a building goes up, said Denise Jillson, executive director of the Harvard Square Business Association.

“We ended up with more storefront space that we probably need,” Jillson said, some of which lacks flexibility and by necessity waits years for the right tenant to come along. McGovern recalled how the need for a coffee shop was written into the zoning where Masse Hardware closed in Observatory Hill, because it was what neighbors wanted. “It stayed vacant for years and now it’s a day care, because nobody wanted to open a coffee shop,” McGovern said.

Others had more reasons why spaces stay empty. Saffari added reasons such as owner retirements and business closings, building sales and “unsuitable rent increases” to the list.

MJ Pullins, a board member of the small-business association Cambridge Local First and owner of the adult boutique Hubba Hubba, said she leased space in a building where four of nine storefronts are vacant. At her building, during recent “ugly” rent negotiations against the backdrop of a fellow tenant leaving because of mold problems, the landlord “straight out said, ‘Hey, we’re going to take this building down in five to 10 years. We’re just holding on to it to sell it.’”

“It’s a tax write-off,” Pullins said, describing the practice of “land banking” – holding onto real estate as an investment without plans for use in the short term.

Meanwhile, there are companies such as CVS that will leave a space but keep paying the rent specifically to keep it unoccupied. The pharmacy chain did that in Harvard Square for at least three years at a prominent location, Jillson said.

Legal limits

Concerns about empty storefronts that deaden street activity, show neglect and invite rats led city councillors and city staff over the past few years to offer business owners financial and technical support as well as storefront improvement equipment and marketing grants, and to run a free Site Finder program for entrepreneurs looking for space. A proposed policy would have called for a property owner to notify city staff within 90 days of a vacancy, pay a registration fee and put paper or art in the windows “so at least it is inviting as people walk by,” Saffari said. Leasing and contact information would also have been required.

At the March 11 meeting, that language was proposed for a staff review before summer – that vacant storefronts would have to be registered with the city and show leasing availability or status in a window.

Owners could be fined up to $300 per day for failure to comply, or more if the city appealed to the state Legislature for a home rule petition, city solicitor Megan Bayer said. But the fine would have to be the same no matter how big or small the owner.

“We do have a public health, safety and general welfare interest in not having blighted business districts,” Bayer said. “But there are some scofflaws who are not really deterred by a $300-a-day fine.” And in the eyes of the law, she said, “a sliding scale wouldn’t make sense if it’s based on the economic situation of the property owner … the fine has to be based on the actual harm that’s caused by the property looking blighted.”

Sparing the small landlord

The law may not be able to make a distinction between big and small property owners, but the city must, said business leaders at the meeting including Monestime, Jillson and Jason Alves, executive director of the East Cambridge Business Association.

“There are different sets of challenges,” Alves said. “There’s a lot of reasons for vacancies, and my main caution is making sure that our small property owners are not lumped in.”

As an example, while a policy for fines was never enacted, a program for beautification of empty storefronts was. It relied on filling windows with art printed on paper or vinyl – at the property owners’ expense. “The artwork can be very cost prohibitive if it’s vinyl,” Saffari said. “That’s one of the reasons why we stopped the program: It actually wasn’t resulting in the results that we all wanted to see, because only the property owners that can afford it could do it.”

Comparing small property owners with the land-banking property owners – meeting chair Toner guessed there were 10 of them – Jillson warned against enacting a law that would feel like a punishment. “Most people are doing the right thing, but those who are deliberately not, they have some other intention. This will not change that,” Jillson said. In her experience, “for the most part, property owners, particularly those with ground-floor retail, have been trying mightily to rent their spaces.”

Print
The Crimson

After Delays, Harvard Square Finally Says Goodbye to The Pit

The Pit — a seating area in Harvard Square — was demolished on Tuesday this week.

The Pit — a seating area in Harvard Square — was demolished on Tuesday this week. By Thomas Maisonneuve

By Jaya N. Karamcheti, Crimson Staff Writer

4 days ago

As part of ongoing renovations to the Harvard Square Plaza, yellow safety vests and work boots replaced black leather jackets and Doc Marten boots from the ’80s during the demolition of The Pit this past Tuesday.

Built in 1982, The Pit, a sunken brick-and-stone seating area, served as a place of “great acceptance” for individuals who were “grunge and punk,” according to Denise A. Jillson, the executive director of the Harvard Square Business Association.

“You could be different, you could be very different, but you would be accepted. And that was really the charm and the magic of the place,” Jillson said.

New construction plans were created to reimagine the aging Harvard Square Kiosk and Plaza to be “flexible, dynamic, and welcoming community assets,” per the Cambridge Department of Public Works website. Specifically, a permanent visitor information center will be built and the space would act as a hub for “community gatherings, including civic, artistic, and social activities.”

Another reason for the redevelopment was to improve the plaza’s accessibility to people with disabilities.

But until this past week — for almost three years — no ground was broken and The Pit remained fenced off to the public. The demolition delays were caused by the Covid-19 pandemic, the difficulties of building near a busy MBTA stop, and “setbacks” from Cambridge’s city government to make an appropriation for the project, according to Jillson.

The Cambridge Department of Public Works said on their website that they expect the project to be completed by summer 2026.

As the area remains under construction, Katie Labrie, the executive director of Cambridge Local First, spoke about how The Pit was not just a seating area — it was a place for anyone that felt they did not fit in.

A self-proclaimed “Pit rat” during her adolescent years, Labrie said the time she spent in The Pit during her adolescent years shaped her into the person and leader she is today.

The Pit allowed her teenager self to “find real, local community, as opposed to fabricated clubs or networks.”

“I always was drawn to living in neighborhoods that had that innate sense of sort of localism,” Labrie said. “If I hadn’t had that experience, I think so many of my life choices would have been different.”

Though Labrie said many of the people she met in The Pit were simply participating in a culture of teenage rebellion, the space had a deeper meaning for others.

“There were a lot of really, really great kids who were not just rebelling,” Labrie said. “They were escaping abusive homes, or they were voluntarily or involuntarily unhoused because their home conditions were intolerable.”

When The Pit was first announced to be remodeled in summer 2022, crowds gathered at Pit-a-Palooza, an event to celebrate “the notorious and revered Harvard Square ‘Pit’ and those who called it home,” according to its event website.

At Pit-a-Palooza, leather-clad attendees danced and moshed to New Wave and 90s punk hits, while second-hand smoke filled the air.

Though the bricks, stones, and the people who sit on them will change after reconstruction, Jillson said she hopes The Pit’s themes of acceptance will remain present.

The “expectation” for The Pit’s redevelopment is that it will be a “welcoming place” for “students and professors and unhoused people and foreigners and immigrants and people of every denomination and every way of identifying,” Jillson said.

After The Pit’s revitalization, Labrie said, “I would love to see music come back to the Square in a real serious way. There’s nothing like taking that escalator up right from the depths of the T and hearing music blasting.”

“It just makes you immediately know where you are and lifts your mood,” she added

Print
CBS

“The Pit” has been demolished. Renderings show what’s next for Harvard Square.

A longtime landmark in Harvard Square is gone. “The Pit” has been demolished as part of a years-long effort to revamp the area in Cambridge, Massachusetts.

The stone and brick seating area adjacent to the Red Line MBTA station served as a gathering spot for decades, but now it’s nothing more than dirt, rocks and mud. 

In 2017, the city started an $8.6 million project to reimagine and reconstruct the Harvard Square Kiosk and plaza. 

The kiosk, previously built as an entrance to the subway station in 1927, became the Out of Town News stand in 1983. It was known for selling newspapers and magazines from around the world before the business closed in 2019.

Cambridge Kiosk
The Cambridge Kiosk in Harvard Square is set to open in early 2025. CBS Boston

Harvard Square kiosk construction delays

The area became an eyesore, fenced in and blocked off from the public for years. The city attributed delays to COVID and work done to preserve the landmark kiosk building. Now the expectation is that a renovated kiosk will open sometime in the next few months.

“The interior of the Kiosk would function as a flexible space accommodating permanent and temporary community uses,” planners say. “Permanent uses would feature a Visitor Information Center with displays focused on Cambridge history and happenings and the provision of news, brochures, and other materials.”

Harvard Square plaza renovations

As for the rest of the plaza, renderings show there wouldn’t be a circular “pit” anymore.

screenshot-20250313-045847.png
A rendering of the reconstructed Harvard Square plaza.City of Cambridge

A project report envisions the plaza as a place for “informal social seating and community gathering,” and also as a temporary use spot for performances, art installations, family friendly activities, outdoor markets and demonstrations.

screenshot-20250313-050635.png
A rendering of the renovated Harvard Square Plaza at night.City of Cambridge

It’s estimated that it could take as much as two more years to finish the construction work.

Print
Boston Globe

End of an era: The Pit, a landmark of Harvard Square, is demolished

The seating area in Harvard Square known as The Pit has been demolished, a new milestone for an ongoing renovation of the plaza on which it sat for decades — and the end of an era.David L. Ryan/Globe Staff

CAMBRIDGE — In its heyday, they called it The Pit.

This week, it’s more like The Swamp.

Construction crews have begun pulverizing the former brick and stone sitting area, which had been a gathering space for young people in the region’s counterculture and those who bonded over not fitting in.

Tuesday, as part of broader Harvard Square renovations, workers scooped out chunks of rock as a pumpsucked brown water and mud pooling at the base of what was once a cherished and infamous landmark.

“There’s a feeling people have for that area, and it has to do with acceptance,” said Denise Jillson, executive director of the Harvard Square Business Association. “Anybody who went in there, regardless of their political persuasion, their race, their sexual persuasion, it didn’t matter. Everybody was welcomed. Even kids that were a little bit odd and outside the mainstream felt welcomed there.”

Jillson said her organization has salvaged several hundred bricks from The Pit, some of which it emblazoned with a metal plaque and sold off for $25 apiece in a fund-raiser for Bridge Over Troubled Waters, a nonprofit that works with homeless youth. About 200 are still stored in her office.

The Pit in Harvard Square before it was demolished.
The Pit in Harvard Square before it was demolished.David L. Ryan/Globe Staff
The Harvard Square Business Association salvaged hundreds of bricks from the landmark known as The Pit before it was demolished. Some, bearing plaques commemorating the landmark, were sold for a fund-raiser.
The Harvard Square Business Association salvaged hundreds of bricks from the landmark known as The Pit before it was demolished. Some, bearing plaques commemorating the landmark, were sold for a fund-raiser. Denise Jillson

Local punks, alternative types, and street performers of all stripes played music, met friends, or simply hung around there with the other young people who showed up there day after day.

One of them was Marc McGovern, now a Cambridge city councilor and the city’s vice mayor, who was a self-described “pit rat” as a teen in the 1980s. (The Business Association this year paid tribute to this little-known aspect of McGovern’s past by gifting him a framed photo of himself taken when he was a spiky-haired high-schooler hanging around in a leather jacket).

He’s still nostalgic for those days all these years later, McGovern said.

“That time of my life was an unsettled time for me, and I found protection and community in The Pit. So it’s really important to me,” McGovern said.

Related: ‘It shouldn’t be this difficult’: Why fixing up a kiosk in Harvard Square is costing millions and taking years

“Pit rats” weren’t always beloved by everyone in the square, he recalls. Some of the kids and young adults who hung around got into trouble with drinking or drug use, and there could be violence. But the space had vast meaning for many and a reputation.

He remembers tourists and families of prospective students got a kick out of seeing real Boston punks so close to the serene Harvard campus. “We used to charge people to take our pictures,” he said.

McGovern hopes the new version of the plaza when it reopens will also offer a place for all kinds of people, perhaps wayward youths included, to go. And that there aren’t calls to shoo away whoever winds up in the plaza.

“Hopefully, it can still be a place where people can gather and meet friends and feel that they’re part of something,” he said.

People who weren’t whiling away afternoons there remember The Pit, too.

The Pit, a seating area considered a counter-cultural landmark in Harvard Square, has been demolished amid an ongoing renovation of the plaza on which it sat for decades.
The Pit, a seating area considered a counter-cultural landmark in Harvard Square, has been demolished amid an ongoing renovation of the plaza on which it sat for decades.David L. Ryan/Globe Staff

It wasn’t exactly John Olsen’s scene, but the 74-year-old said that while growing up in the area, he appreciated that The Pit existed as a refuge for the people who found camaraderie there.

“ It had its pluses and minuses, but it was home to a lot of people,” said Olsen, a retired architect who lives in Winchester, who was out for a stroll through the square on a recent springlike morning.

He said he has had mixed feelings about the changes that have come to the neighborhood over time, but believes the new spaces being built by the city to replace the old can themselves become as beloved as The Pit once was.

“It’s a very different place than it was when I was here in my younger years, but I’m growing to appreciate it now,” Olsen said of the square. “I just hope that it develops its own character over the years.”

By the 2010s, when talk began of renovating the plaza to bring it up to modern standards of urban design and accessibility, it had begun to show its age.

The project has been delayed again and again amid a combination of supply chain issues and the difficulties of building in a crowded intersection atop a troubled MBTA stop.

Demolition work on the plaza began recently, Cambridge spokesperson Jeremy Warnick said.

Related: Harvard Square was never what it used to be

People with fond feelings for the landmark held a well-attended goodbye ceremony in June 2022 called Pit-A-Palooza that featured a “Rocky Horror Picture Show” tribute and a rowdy performance from the Boston hardcore punk band Colin of Arabia.

“Dress the part – drag out your fishnets, leather and studs!” an invitation to the party read. “Show your kids how cool you were!”

During the festivities, the city officially proclaimed June 25 as “Pit Rat Day.”

It stayed open to the public for nearly three more years as other work in the plaza got underway.

Now, it’s gone.

Peri Onipede, of Watertown, liked to rest in the Harvard Square seating area known as The Pit area on warm days. But a renovation was long overdue, she said.
Peri Onipede, of Watertown, liked to rest in the Harvard Square seating area known as The Pit area on warm days. But a renovation was long overdue, she said.David L. Ryan/Globe Staff

Given The Pit’s state of disrepair in its latter days, that’s for the better, said Peri Onipede, of Watertown, as she stopped to grab a coffee at a nearby café.

“Just walking through it, there would be water puddles and ice, so you had to be careful,” Onipede said. “I know it was popular with the kids and the students, but I always felt I had to walk carefully through The Pit.”

So she won’t miss it. She hopes the renovation turns the spot into a more accessible place for people to spend time, and considers it a good sign that the plaza renovation will preserve the kiosk that was the longtime home of Out of Town News, which she frequented.

The plans for the kiosk call for it to be a combination information booth and a pop-up.

Overall, Onipede said she just wants the plaza project to be done with already — for the construction to stop, for all the barricades to be removed, and for the next phase of the square, however, it will be, to begin.

“It’s long overdue,” she said. “It’s been closed for so long, and it’s just been an eyesore for a number of years now. I hope there will be something attractive that brings people here.”

Construction barriers and fences block off the plaza in Harvard Square, which is being renovated.
Construction barriers and fences block off the plaza in Harvard Square, which is being renovated.David L. Ryan/Globe Staff
Print
Boston Globe

Good riddance to The Pit

Many people have fond memories of the Harvard Square landmark. But The Pit had a dark side that shouldn’t be glossed over.

Twenty-one-year-old Io Nachtwey in the spring of 2001, shortly before she came to Cambridge and several months before her murder.
Twenty-one-year-old Io Nachtwey in the spring of 2001, shortly before she came to Cambridge and several months before her murder.

Io Nachtwey’s doomed life in The Pit, the circular brick plaza above the Harvard Square T station, began sometime in the summer of 2001. Originally from Hawaii, she was 22 and homeless when she drifted into Cambridge. She quickly joined a loose-knit community of misfits who loitered and skateboarded in and around The Pit, often panhandling and sleeping on nearby streets or in graveyards.

Within a few months, she was dead — murdered in an especially savage attack.

On Tuesday, the Globe reported that the city had demolished the Pit, which originally opened in 1982, provoking an outpouring of nostalgia for the days when “pit kids” (or, to some people, “pit rats”) gave Harvard Square a grittier punk vibe. A mythology seems to have emerged that back in its heyday, The Pit provided a welcoming environment for troubled teens and runaways, who returned the favor by keeping the soul of “real” Harvard Square alive before the ATMs and high-end boutiques took over.

“Anybody who went in there, regardless of their political persuasion, their race, their sexual persuasion, it didn’t matter. Everybody was welcomed. Even kids that were a little bit odd and outside the mainstream felt welcomed there,” Denise Jillson, the executive director of the Harvard Square Business Association, told the Globe.

I don’t mean to argue with people who have happy memories of their time in The Pit. And it’s certainly true that The Pit in the daytime was a less menacing place than it was at night.

Related

Readers recall their halcyon Harvard Square daysHarvard Square was never what it used to beEnd of an era: The Pit, a landmark of Harvard Square, is demolished

But anyone tempted to romanticize The Pit and all it supposedly represented should read about Nachtwey’s death. The Pit “community” didn’t welcome her. It quite literally killed her. Described as sweet and naive, Nachtwey was raped, stabbed by another Pit regular, finished off with a nunchuck blow to the head, and then dumped into the Charles River.

Former Suffolk District Attorney Dan Conley, who prosecuted hundreds of homicides in 17 years in office, said Nachtwey’s killing was “one of the most horrific, horrifying murders in my time as DA.”

“This young woman was truly an innocent kid,” he told me. Four people were convicted in her murder; two others pleaded guilty to lesser charges in exchange for their testimony.

It was not the only crime associated with The Pit. As an announcement for Cambridge’s 2022 “Pit-a-palooza” gingerly acknowledged, “[s]ome of the rats were victims of violence and sexual assault and their experiences are the dark side of this otherwise positive experience.”

You think?

There are, obviously, crimes in every setting. But the rose-tinted nostalgia for the era of The Pit kids strikes me as deeply misplaced, and a continuation of the willful indifference by many Cantabrigians to The Pit’s “dark side” that set the stage for Nachtwey’s death in the first place.

Many of the kids who slept in and around The Pit needed help, and maybe they would have received it if more people in Cambridge had viewed The Pit as a problem and not as a perverse source of pride. Cambridge wore its willingness to let Pit kids sleep on the street as some kind of badge of countercultural honor. Embracing The Pit flattered Cambridge’s self-image as a Bohemian enclave; it also left the kids themselves in danger.

“The street is a very dangerous place, it’s a dangerous environment for anybody,” Conley said.

What does it matter? The Pit kids are long gone, and now so is The Pit itself. But there’s still plenty of homelessness, and plenty of dispute over what to do about it. So mourn the end of an era if you must — you can even buy a brick salvaged from The Pit, with the proceeds going to a charity that supports homeless youth. But hopefully the next time some vulnerable young person like Nachtwey ends up here, there’s no pit quite so deep waiting for them.